Keller-Brown Insurance Services
9 S Main St, PO Box 215
Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania 17361
Phone:  (717) 235-6891(717) 235-6891
Toll Free: (800) 785-7461(800) 785-7461

Melissa Yealy

Photo of Melissa Yealy

Melissa Yealy


Department:   Sales Team
Commercial Lines Inside Producer
Phone:   717-235-6891   Ext: 102
Direct Line:   717-942-5030
Fax:   717-235-3511

Shippensburg State College

She's active.  She's curious.  She's a team player.  She has experience in other industries that help her relate to our commercial customers.  She has all the qualities that make her a perfect fit with the Keller-Brown family.  You're going to love learning about our Melissa Yealy. 

I joined Keller-Brown in 2018 after making the bold move to change careers and jump into the world of insurance. I was impressed by the company culture and felt right at home with the team members I met. I was also drawn in by the promise of a supportive network of teammates, the opportunity for continued education, and the high standard of customer service Keller-Brown strives for. As you walk through the agency building, you get a sense of the legacy laid out over 5 generations of the family business and their company values of family, integrity, diligence and loyalty. These values were a huge draw to me. There is a history of over 120 years of customer service excellence within these office walls!

After graduating from Delone Catholic High School and Shippensburg University earning a Bachelor's degree in Regional Development and Planning, I spent the first 9 years of my career in office roles in the South Central PA area. I worked at a property management company, a commercial construction company, a municipal codes office, and a tool manufacturing corporation. All of these roles prepared me for working with the client accounts I service at Keller-Brown Insurance Services.

When switching careers, my goals included a shorter commute and the opportunity to thrive in my professional career by helping others. I have had a couple of instances of my own where my own insurance has stepped in and saved the day, so I know how important it is to have coverage when you need it.

My main focus as a Commercial Insurance Protection Analyst is servicing existing farm and business accounts, and helping new clients by researching new policies with the best coverage, with the best carrier, at the best price. I always aim to represent Keller-Brown by sticking to the company values and giving top notch customer service to every client.

Continued education has always been a passion of mine and I have taken pride in gaining professional certifications in each of my positions. Shortly after becoming employed at Keller-Brown, I obtained my Property and Casualty Producer License in PA and MD, and have already started working toward my Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) certification, which can take up to 5 years to complete. So far, I have added my Life & Health License.

Around the office, I am happy to be involved in the KB Cares Committee, where I use my catering and entertaining skills to plan company gatherings, and participate in community outreach with company sponsored volunteering opportunities.

In my spare time I enjoy staying busy. I am involved in two local networking groups: The Gals that Brunch York Chapter and RAYAC. I have two border collies, am an amateur photographer for family and friends, and also work as a Realtor for Howard Hanna. I enjoy cooking so much that I host an annual "Friendsgiving Dinner" at my house for family and friends in honor of my favorite holiday. I have had many blessings in my life and am now to the point where I am lucky enough to be able to give back, on both personal and professional levels. I guess one word to sum me up would be "Thankful"!

 "Melissa Yealy is a total rock star! I was in desperate need of Commercial Liability Insurance, with a strict deadline. I called Melissa and she was not only super friendly but she assured me that everything would work out and that she would give me 100% of her focus until the job was accomplished! Thank you to Melissa for saving the day and for helping me obtain the insurance I needed fast and easy!"

Laurie, May 2019

"We contacted Keller-Brown needing an auto insurance policy ASAP. Erin Gladfelter and Melissa Yealy worked with us to insure our vehicle with coverage we could afford and were comfortable with. They made sure all of our questions were answered. We'd highly recommend Keller-Brown to anyone needing insurance. Thanks for being there for us and making the process so easy! "

Essy, August 2019

"Love every bit of my experience with Melissa! She is by far the best to work with."

Chris, May 15 2019



View our Company Directory